Build: #9 failed Changes by Shawn Booth
Code commits
Pipeline
-
Shawn Booth 35c7e299b3a096a0f12a1c26ce3ba5b9a8f83a73
Phase 4: Implement results slimming and delta metadata with investigation tooling
IMPLEMENTATION
--------------
Results Slimming Infrastructure:
- Added Results.slim_for_pickle() method to remove transient fields before serialization
- Implemented _transient_fields support on 5 flagging task result classes:
* BandpassflagResults, GfluxscaleflagResults, PolcalflagResults
* TargetflagResults, TsysflagResults
- Modified ResultsProxy.write() to automatically slim results during pickle dump
Metadata Delta Tracking:
- Implemented ContextDeltaMetadata dataclass for per-stage progression tracking
- Added export_context_delta_metadata() to generate stage-level YAML deltas
- Created Context.save_metadata() API for lightweight metadata-only snapshots
- Per-stage exports: context-stageN-delta.yaml, context-stageN-metadata.yaml
Investigation Tooling:
- audit_storage_reduction.py: Component-by-component storage analysis
- check_dataset_size.py: Dataset suitability checker for optimization testing
- drill_imaging_products.py: Detailed imaging product size breakdown
- estimate_results_slimming.py: Post-hoc slimming benefit estimation
- debug_pickle_contents.py: Pickle content inspection utility
TESTING & VALIDATION
--------------------
Controlled testing performed on multiple datasets:
- Small dataset (ALMA-IF, 914 KB context, 48 stages): No measurable improvement
- Large dataset (44 MB context, 56 stages, 24 GB results): 0% storage savings
Result pickle slimming analysis on production data:
- 21 GB stage 4 pickle: 0.0% reduction
- 1.5 GB stage 7 pickle: 0.0% reduction
- 944 MB stages 13/19: 0.1% reduction (within measurement noise)
Findings: Large result pickles are dominated by calibration data/arrays, not plots.
Phase 4 optimizations provide no measurable benefit on tested datasets.
DOCUMENTATION
-------------
- Updated EXECUTIVE_SUMMARY.md with Phase 4 status and testing results
- Updated INVESTIGATION_SUMMARY.md with honest assessment
- Updated CONTEXT_STORAGE_INVESTIGATION.md with implementation details
- Updated COMPLETE_IMPLEMENTATION_SUMMARY.md with negative results section
- Created PHASE4_RESULTS.md with comprehensive testing metrics
FILES CHANGED
-------------
Core implementation: 5 result objects + 3 infrastructure files (242 lines)
Investigation tools: 5 new utilities (934 lines)
Documentation: 5 markdown files updated (268 lines)
Total: 18 files, 1,444 insertions
RECOMMENDATION
--------------
While Phase 4 infrastructure is correctly implemented with zero functional
regressions, controlled testing reveals no storage or performance improvements
on representative datasets. This represents honest negative results from a
properly executed investigation.
The investigation tooling and testing methodology developed during this phase
remain valuable for future context optimization work.- docs/source/context_serialization/COMPLETE_IMPLEMENTATION_SUMMARY.md (version 35c7e299b3a096a0f12a1c26ce3ba5b9a8f83a73) (diffs)
- docs/source/context_serialization/CONTEXT_STORAGE_INVESTIGATION.md (version 35c7e299b3a096a0f12a1c26ce3ba5b9a8f83a73) (diffs)
- docs/source/context_serialization/EXECUTIVE_SUMMARY.md (version 35c7e299b3a096a0f12a1c26ce3ba5b9a8f83a73) (diffs)
- docs/source/context_serialization/INVESTIGATION_SUMMARY.md (version 35c7e299b3a096a0f12a1c26ce3ba5b9a8f83a73) (diffs)
- docs/source/context_serialization/PHASE4_RESULTS.md (version 35c7e299b3a096a0f12a1c26ce3ba5b9a8f83a73) (diffs)
- pipeline/h/tasks/tsysflag/resultobjects.py (version 35c7e299b3a096a0f12a1c26ce3ba5b9a8f83a73) (diffs)
- pipeline/hifa/tasks/bandpassflag/resultobjects.py (version 35c7e299b3a096a0f12a1c26ce3ba5b9a8f83a73) (diffs)
- pipeline/hifa/tasks/gfluxscaleflag/resultobjects.py (version 35c7e299b3a096a0f12a1c26ce3ba5b9a8f83a73) (diffs)
- pipeline/hifa/tasks/polcalflag/polcalflag.py (version 35c7e299b3a096a0f12a1c26ce3ba5b9a8f83a73) (diffs)
- pipeline/hifa/tasks/targetflag/targetflag.py (version 35c7e299b3a096a0f12a1c26ce3ba5b9a8f83a73) (diffs)
- pipeline/infrastructure/basetask.py (version 35c7e299b3a096a0f12a1c26ce3ba5b9a8f83a73) (diffs)
- pipeline/infrastructure/launcher.py (version 35c7e299b3a096a0f12a1c26ce3ba5b9a8f83a73) (diffs)
- pipeline/infrastructure/serializers.py (version 35c7e299b3a096a0f12a1c26ce3ba5b9a8f83a73) (diffs)
- tools/audit_storage_reduction.py (version 35c7e299b3a096a0f12a1c26ce3ba5b9a8f83a73) (diffs)
- tools/check_dataset_size.py (version 35c7e299b3a096a0f12a1c26ce3ba5b9a8f83a73) (diffs)
- tools/debug_pickle_contents.py (version 35c7e299b3a096a0f12a1c26ce3ba5b9a8f83a73) (diffs)
- tools/drill_imaging_products.py (version 35c7e299b3a096a0f12a1c26ce3ba5b9a8f83a73) (diffs)
- tools/estimate_results_slimming.py (version 35c7e299b3a096a0f12a1c26ce3ba5b9a8f83a73) (diffs)